3400, 10180 101 St NW, Edmonton, AB T5J 3S424/7 service 1 (800) 716-8955
  1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Backup power and security
  4. Standby vs portable generators: which one fits your home
Backup power and security

Standby vs portable generators: which one fits your home

A plain comparison of permanently installed standby generators and portable units with an inlet, so you can match backup power to how you actually live through an Edmonton outage.

7 min readFor homeowners2 illustrations

Two ways to keep the lights on

Most Edmonton outages are short. A few are not, and the long ones tend to arrive with a January cold snap or a summer windstorm. That is when people start asking about generators.

There are two common setups for homes. A portable generator lives in the garage and gets wheeled out when you need it. A standby generator is installed permanently outside on a pad, runs on natural gas or propane, and starts by itself when the grid drops.

Both can be safe and useful. Both must be connected through proper transfer equipment, never through a dryer plug or a cord jammed into a wall outlet. The choice comes down to how much you want backed up, who will be home to run it, and how much hands-on work you are willing to do at -30 C.

FIG 01Alberta Electrical
Two houses side by side. Left: a wheeled portable generator outside, a cord to an inlet box on the wall, and an interlock kit on the main panel. Right: a fixed standby generator on a concrete pad with a gas line, wired to an automatic transfer switch beside the main panel.PORTABLE + INLETinterlock kitinlet boxportable unitpanelSTANDBY + ATSautomatic transfer switchmain panelstandby unit on padgas supply
A portable generator feeds the house through an inlet box and a panel interlock, while a standby unit on a pad feeds an automatic transfer switch.

Portable generators with an inlet

A portable unit is the flexible option. You buy the generator, and a licensed (journeyperson) electrician installs a power inlet box on the outside wall and a transfer switch or listed interlock kit at your panel. During an outage you set the generator up outdoors, plug a heavy cord into the inlet, and choose which circuits to run.

  • Works well for keeping the furnace, fridge, sump pump, some lights and the internet running.
  • Lower upfront complexity: no gas line and no concrete pad.
  • Needs fuel on hand. Gasoline goes stale and storing a lot of it is its own hazard.
  • Someone has to be home, awake and able to go outside to start it.
  • Cold starts can be tough. Many portables struggle in deep cold unless they are kept warm and well maintained.

Read more about the connection side in why backfeeding is dangerous.

SafetyNever run it inside

Portable generators make carbon monoxide. Run one only outdoors, well away from doors, windows and air intakes, never in a garage, even with the door open.

Standby generators with an automatic transfer switch

A standby generator is a fixed appliance. It sits on a pad beside the house, connects to your gas supply, and pairs with an automatic transfer switch (ATS). When utility power fails, the ATS signals the generator to start, waits for it to stabilize, then moves your house over. When the grid returns, it switches back and lets the engine cool down before shutting off.

  • Starts within seconds, whether you are home or away at the lake.
  • Can be sized for essential circuits or the whole house.
  • Runs on piped natural gas, so there is no refuelling in a storm.
  • Exercises itself on a schedule so you know it is ready.
  • Needs a gas permit and gas fitter as well as electrical work, and placement has to respect clearances to windows, vents, property lines and the gas meter.

Because the house switches over automatically, a standby system is the usual choice for people with medical equipment, a basement that floods without a sump pump, pets at home, or travel during winter.

FIG 02Alberta Electrical
Two rows of five steps. Portable: power fails, go outside and set up, start and plug in, move the interlock, switch on loads. Standby: power fails, transfer switch senses it, generator starts, switch moves the house to generator, and returns to grid automatically.PORTABLE: YOU DO THE WORKpower failsgo outside,set up unitstart it andplug in cordmove interlockto generatorswitch onloadsSTANDBY: IT HAPPENS ON ITS OWNpower failsATS sensesloss of gridgeneratorstartsATS moveshouse to genreturns whengrid is backShaded box: the step that needs the most attention in each approach.
What happens in an outage with a portable setup compared to an automatic standby system.

Side by side

FactorPortable with inletStandby with ATS
Start-upManual, someone must be homeAutomatic, within seconds
FuelGasoline or dual-fuel, stored on siteNatural gas or propane supply
CoverageSelected circuitsEssentials or whole home
Cold weatherCan be hard to startOften has cold-weather kit options
PermitsElectrical permit for the inlet and switchElectrical and gas permits
NoiseUsually louderEnclosed, usually quieter

Neither column says anything about price on purpose. Cost depends on generator size, how far the unit sits from the panel and gas meter, whether your gas meter can supply the extra load, and whether your electrical service needs work first.

Questions that point you to the right one

  1. Who will be home when the power fails? If the answer is sometimes nobody, lean toward standby.
  2. What must keep running? A short list (furnace, fridge, sump, a few lights) suits a portable. Air conditioning, an electric range or a well pump points toward a larger standby unit.
  3. How long do you expect to run it? For multi-day events, piped gas beats hauling jerry cans.
  4. What is your panel like? Older 60 A and 100 A services in Edmonton homes sometimes need an upgrade before any transfer equipment can be added cleanly.
  5. Where can it physically go? Standby units need a suitable spot with required clearances, which some infill lots make tight.

Our guide to sizing a backup generator walks through the load side in more detail.

What the installation involves

Either way, the job starts with a look at your panel and a list of the loads you care about. The electrician confirms the transfer method, pulls the electrical permit (in Edmonton, through the City; elsewhere in Alberta, through your local permit authority or an accredited agency), and coordinates any gas work with a licensed gas fitter.

Once installed, the system is inspected, tested under load, and you are shown how to operate it. For standby units, ask about a maintenance plan so the exercise cycle, battery and oil are checked before winter.

TipWrite down your must-run list

Before anyone visits, walk the house and list what you would miss most in a 12-hour winter outage. That list drives every other decision.

Common questions

Can I just plug a portable generator into a wall outlet?

No. A so-called suicide cord can energize the utility lines and injure lineworkers or neighbours, and it can damage your home's wiring. Use an inlet box with a transfer switch or listed interlock installed under permit.

Will a standby generator run my whole house?

It can if it is sized for it. Many homeowners choose an essential-circuits setup instead, or use load management modules that shed big loads like an air conditioner while the generator is running.

Do standby generators work at -30 C?

They are built for outdoor use, and cold-weather options such as battery warmers and block heaters help. Regular exercise and pre-winter maintenance matter more than anything else.

Do I need a permit for a portable generator inlet?

Yes. Installing an inlet and transfer equipment is electrical work that needs a permit under the Alberta Safety Codes Act, and in Edmonton the City issues it.

About this guideGeneral information, not a site assessment

Codes and permit rules change and every building is different. For work on your system, talk to a licensed electrician and your local permit authority.

Keep reading

More on backup power and security

All 13 guides →
Backup power and security · 7 min

Home battery backup vs a generator: how to choose

Batteries are quiet and automatic but finite; generators run as long as fuel lasts. How each works, how they suit Edmonton winters, and when a combination makes sense.

Read the guide →
Backup power and security · 7 min

UPS systems for businesses: a practical buyer's guide

How uninterruptible power supplies protect servers, point-of-sale and controls, the difference between UPS types, and what to plan for runtime, wiring and batteries.

Read the guide →
Backup power and security · 7 min

Powering a server or data room: what to plan for

Dedicated circuits, UPS, redundant feeds, cooling and generator backup for small server rooms and network closets in offices, clinics and light industrial buildings.

Read the guide →

Need an electrician?

Call the 24/7 line or send a request and we'll set up a consultation and a free estimate.

Call 24/7Request service