You do not need a hospital-sized system
Large towers and hospitals have dedicated operators and complex building automation. Most commercial buildings in Edmonton, Calgary and smaller Alberta and BC communities are not like that. They have a few rooftop units, some unit heaters, exhaust fans, lighting and maybe a boiler, and a manager who looks after building systems as one job among many.
Those buildings can still get real value from automation: equipment that runs only when needed, alerts before pipes freeze, and one place to see what is going on. The trick is choosing a level of system that matches the building and the people running it.
Typical options
| Option | Suits | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Programmable thermostats | One or two units, simple schedules | No central view, easy to override, no alarms |
| Networked or cloud thermostats | Several units, owner wants remote access | Limited control of non-HVAC equipment; depends on the vendor's cloud service |
| Small open-protocol BAS | Multiple units plus exhaust, lighting, metering and alarms | Needs a competent installer and some service |
| Full DDC BAS | Central plants, air handlers, many zones | Higher cost and more expertise to run |
A building often moves up the ladder over time. That is fine, provided earlier choices do not lock you in.
What to connect first
- Heating and ventilation schedules, the largest and quickest savings in most buildings.
- Freeze and low-temperature alarms for mechanical rooms, sprinkler rooms and vestibules. In an Alberta winter this alone can justify the system.
- Exhaust fans and make-up air that are often left running 24/7.
- Lighting schedules for parking lots, signs and common areas, through lighting control systems.
- The main meter or key sub-meters, so you can see what changes actually save. See sub-metering and energy dashboards.
If budget is tight, start with schedules and alarms. Fancy optimization routines are worth little if nobody hears about a failed boiler until the pipes freeze.
Choosing a system you can live with
The biggest long-term risk in small-building automation is lock-in: a system only one company can service, with passwords and software you do not control. Ask these questions before you sign:
- Does it use an open protocol such as BACnet, so other contractors can work on it later?
- Will you receive administrator credentials, the programs and the graphics?
- Are there ongoing licence or cloud subscription fees, and what happens if you stop paying?
- Can it grow to more equipment without replacing the core?
- Who in your area can service it, besides the installer?
- How is remote access secured? See cybersecurity for building and plant controls.
Making it stick
Automation only works if people trust it. Involve the people who get the complaints: a receptionist or store manager who knows which rooms are always cold is a valuable source of information. Give them a simple way to request a temporary override that expires on its own, rather than a thermostat they can lock at 26 C.
Plan for a short check-in visit after the first heating season and the first cooling season. Schedules and setpoints almost always need adjusting once real occupancy patterns show up in the trends.
Training does not need to be long. Half a day for the building manager covering schedules, holidays, alarm acknowledgement and how to read a trend is usually enough to make the system theirs rather than the contractor's.
A basic service agreement that reviews alarms, overrides and schedules a couple of times a year keeps the savings from drifting away. For a deeper look at how a full system works, read what a building automation system does.
Electrical considerations
A BAS adds controllers, power supplies, relays and low-voltage wiring, and connecting to rooftop units, unit heaters and lighting circuits involves line-voltage work that needs a licensed electrician and a permit where required. In Alberta that goes through the local permit authority or the City of Edmonton; in BC, Technical Safety BC or the local authority.
Our BAS installation, HVAC controls and energy metering services cover the controls and the electrical work together, so one team owns the result.
Common questions
Is a BAS worth it for a single-storey retail unit?
Often a networked thermostat system with a couple of alarms is the right fit. If you also have exhaust fans, signs, parking lot lighting and a walk-in cooler, a small BAS may pay off. It depends on the equipment and how it is used today.
Can we reuse our existing thermostats?
Sometimes. Some communicating thermostats can be integrated, but many are better replaced with room sensors connected to a controller.
What happens if the internet goes down?
A well-designed BAS keeps running its schedules locally. Cloud-only systems may lose some functions, so ask how the system behaves offline.
Does a BAS help with energy rebates or codes?
Controls can be part of energy efficiency programs and are sometimes required by energy codes for new work or major renovations. Requirements vary, so check the current program rules and with the permit authority.
Codes and permit rules change and every building is different. For work on your system, talk to a licensed electrician and your local permit authority.